Wedding Cake Decorated

Wedding & Custom Cakes

For over a quarter century, the Shepherdstown Sweet Shop has specialized in creating custom wedding cakes, designed uniquely for each bridal couple to complement the style of their wedding celebration.

Every day is someone’s birthday – make it special with a custom decorated cake in one of our many flavors of cakes, icings and fillings. Browse through our portfolio of birthday and special occasion cakes, or treat your dinner guests to one of our deliciously decadent fancy dessert cakes.



Slice of Cake

Cake Flavors




White Almond



Red Velvet

Carrot Cake


Special Order Flavors (5 to 7 day notice)





White Chocolate Marble

White Red Velvet Marble

Chocolate Rum

Vanilla Rum

Frosting .jpg


White Buttercream

Light Cream Cheese

Almond Cream

Lemon Cream

Orange Cream

Raspberry Cream

Strawberry Cream


Chocolate Mocha

Chocolate Buttercream

Chocolate Fudge

Peanut Butter


Coconut Pecan



European Raspberry

Golden Lemon

Chocolate Fudge

Chocolate Ganache

Bavarian Custard

Whole Strawberry

Whole Cherry

Fresh Fruit (seasonal)

Wedding Cake

Wedding Cakes

You tie the knot. We’ll frost the cake.

Your wedding is a special and cherished moment in your life, and you deserve the perfect cake to celebrate. One that’s delicious and beautifully decorated to match your colors and reception.

That’s where we come in: You can count on us to give you the very best. We’ll make a custom cake that feeds as many people as you need and looks the way you want.

As you browse our cake flavors, icing and fillings, know that we can customize nearly anything. Just ask us! Want more tiers or a smaller cake? Consider it done. Let’s start planning!

Cutting Cake

Other Occasions

Weddings are just one of life’s special moments that we can help you celebrate. We can create beautiful cakes for bridal and baby showers, groom’s cakes, and cakes for special occasions, including milestone anniversary celebrations and quinceañeras. Let us help make every celebration a sweet one.

Happy Birthday Cake

Custom Cakes

Your life’s special events are important, and as such, your cake should be extraordinary. Our birthday cakes are made fresh in store using only the finest of ingredients.

Company Policy

1. If you are unhappy with your order, bring the matter to attention before you leave Shepherdstown Sweet Shop. Once you leave the bakery with your order, we cannot help you solve any issues – all sales are final.

2. You will be asked to sign a waiver on relatable cakes (2 tiers or more) when picking up the cake yourself. This release states that the order was acceptable to your preference, and once you leave the bakery, the cake becomes your responsibility.

3.We will put your cake in a box depending on the size (height and width) of the cake.